Luigi Mangione’s NYC Defense Attorney

Meet Karen Friedman Agnifilo, Esq.

Before Luigi Mangione was even identified and arrested—when all we had was that charming, smiling photo supposedly taken at the Midtown Hostel—I had serious doubts that authorities would apprehend the suspect without resorting to lethal force. The whole thing felt orchestrated, like a scene straight out of a federal playbook. Still, I told my group of friends—who are deeply invested in following the case—that if a suspect were to be taken into custody alive, one of the most revealing aspects would be the defense attorney they secured and, more importantly, who was footing the bill.

Meet Karen Friedman Agnifilo, the formidable attorney stepping into the spotlight as the New York defense counsel for Luigi Mangione, the 26-year-old Ivy Leaguer accused of fatally shooting UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. With a legal career spanning over three decades, Karen’s expertise is as vast as it is impressive.

While the specifics of Ms. Agnifilo’s legal fees remain undisclosed without access to her retainer agreement with Mangione, it is reasonable to infer that his affluent Maryland family is covering the cost of his defense. Prior to Mangione’s arrest, I was uncertain whether this case pointed to a professional hitman scenario or a vigilante act. In hindsight, it no longer fits neatly into either category. However, I believed at the time that if a suspect were apprehended, the nature of their legal representation—whether a court-appointed public defender or a high-profile private attorney—would provide valuable insight into their background and motivations. Since Mangione’s arrest, it has come to light that he hails from a wealthy family with significant ties to the assisted living industry, making it highly plausible that they are financing his defense.

Notably, no members of Mangione’s family have been present at his court hearings thus far—a detail that has not gone unnoticed by the media and has been spun to suggest a lack of familial support. However, a more plausible explanation is that his family fully supports him but has chosen to maintain a low profile, understanding the risks of fueling the media spectacle and providing the press with further opportunities to sensationalize the case.

Before transitioning to defense work, Karen served as the Chief Assistant District Attorney in Manhattan, where she oversaw more than 500 attorneys and managed a $120 million budget. During her tenure, she played pivotal roles in high-profile cases, including the prosecutions of Harvey Weinstein and Allen Weisselberg. She was instrumental in establishing specialized units such as the Human Trafficking Unit, Hate Crimes Unit, and the Cybercrimes and Identity Theft Bureau. Karen’s deep understanding of the legal system is further enriched by her time as General Counsel to the New York City Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice under Mayor Michael Bloomberg. Her commitment to justice and reform has been a consistent thread throughout her career.

It’s always interesting to me how many lawyers who work as prosecutors for long periods of time end up being extremely highly-sought after private defense attorneys. In a twist that could be straight out of a legal drama, Karen’s husband, Marc Agnifilo, is also a prominent defense attorney currently representing Sean “Diddy” Combs in a federal trial. This power couple’s simultaneous involvement in two of the nation’s most talked-about cases has certainly turned heads.

Karen’s approach to Mangione’s defense has been both strategic and compelling—aligning closely with what I would have pursued in her position. She has publicly criticized the handling of his extradition and arraignment, describing it as “the biggest staged perp walk I’ve ever seen in my career,” and accused New York City officials, including Mayor Eric Adams, of using the case for political purposes. Such statements hint at a defense strategy that may challenge not just the charges against Mangione, but also the broader context in which the case is being prosecuted.

As the legal proceedings unfold, all eyes will be on Karen Friedman Agnifilo. With her extensive experience, strategic acumen, and unflinching dedication to her clients, she’s poised to be a formidable force in the courtroom. Personally, I’m already a huge fan of whoever’s legal strategy it was for her and Luigi to appear in matching outfits at the December 23, 2024 NY State Criminal hearing, in which Luigi pled not guilty to all eleven NY State criminal charges.

 

 

 

 

I am anxiously awaiting to see if their outfits for court appearances will continue to coordinate in any manner.

Subscribe for exclusive Luigi Mangione trial coverage, which will start being available to Paid Subscribers only starting February 16, 2025—just before my first day of live coverage from New York City beginning February 17, 2025.

To Subscribe, click link below: 

An Astonishing Achievement | Lauren Davidson-Ibarra | Substack